You know, through the years you hear so many complaints about breeder judges at Labrador specialties.
Here at Overlook, we’ve never really had a problem with breeder judges at specialties. Sure, we’ve had a few bad breaks over the years, but we’ve also done well. Most of the time the judging has been fair, and the experience has been enjoyable.
Over time, you learn the process. You figure out what types certain breeder judges prefer and what they don’t, and then you choose which specialties are the best fit for you and your dogs. It’s pretty simple and straightforward.
Breeder judges are generally well educated in the breed, and at the end of the day they usually reward the dog they believe is the best.
I think the bigger issue in Labradors is something entirely different.
There are six to eight AKC all breed judges who handle the majority of Labrador, Sporting Group and Best in Show assignments. Everyone knows who they are. There’s no need to call anyone out.
Somehow, these six to eight judges—who are widely recognized as Labrador enthusiasts rather than breeders—have more influence over the overall rankings than our breeder judges. In many ways, those enthusiast judges have more control over the future direction and visibility of the breed than the breeder judges themselves.
That seems broken.
Those judges have tremendous influence over which Labradors rise to the top in all-breed competition.
They play a significant role in building momentum—or stopping it.
If you’re in favor with those particular six to eight judges, the opportunities are there. If you’re not, the road becomes much harder.
I think it’s worth discussing whether judging assignments should be limited within certain breeds to help level the playing field. Breeder judges should probably receive more assignments in their breed than all-breed judges.
Pay attention to the patterns. Watch who travels where and when. A lot of the questions people ask will answer themselves.
That kind of observation can save you a lot of travel, time and money.
Of course, there are times when the situation is unavoidable, especially at major events where it’s more important for a dog to be seen by the public than to focus on one judge’s opinion.
Just pay attention to the patterns.
Leave a Reply